Who would win in a fight...

Stephen Cheney

Offline

Since it's such a big part of the advertising, let's do some VS discussions. The only rule for answers is that you must create a plausible scenario for the victory of your choice, rather than just saying who you think would win.

FIRST ROUND: Captain Malcolm Reynolds vs. Captain Han Solo
Location: Any generic wretched hive of scum and villainy/spaceport
Limitation: No crew to assist

~Stephen
DigiTribe Developer

I'm pretty sure he was happy with his final resting place
because he was buried on the mountain,
and that...
was against the law.

Comments

Who would win in a fight...

Wow..um,...I think I would have to say Han would just escape if he could , but otherwise Mal would so kick his ass. :wink:

Mirv | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 11:33

Who would win in a fight...

I've got to go with Han here. Why? Because he'd shoot first!

John Kazuo Morehead | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 11:33

Who would win in a fight...

John Kazuo Morehead wrote:
I've got to go with Han here. Why? Because he'd shoot first!

See, honestly, in that situation, I see both of them losing as they both simultaneously try to shoot first. Reference Mal vs the Operator.

Stephen Cheney | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 12:14

Who would win in a fight...

I agree.. Han would shoot first

April Fall McCl... | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 12:57

Who would win in a fight...

No clue about the Malcolm fella, sounds like a sci-fi jobber. Han wins, probably by feeding Malcolm to the Sarlaac.

Erik Ellickson | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 21:42

Who would win in a fight...

There is no way Mal loses to Han. I am huge SW fan, but I think Mal is just a tad meaner than Han. He, Mal, has more of a survival instinct.

Mirv | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 22:27

Who would win in a fight...

Erik Ellickson wrote:
No clue about the Malcolm fella, sounds like a sci-fi jobber. Han wins, probably by feeding Malcolm to the Sarlaac.

hehe

Han: "Captain Malcolm Reynolds? From Serenity Valley? Where?" ::turn, klunk::
Mal: "Oh, dangit!" ::falls::

Stephen Cheney | Mon, 07/10/2006 - 23:05

Who would win in a fight...

MAL ... are you kidding?!

What in the hell did Han do with his life according to the original trilogy that would give him any form of credit of being anything but a pirate and a scoundrel?

Mal on the other hand was a browncoat. He was a military leader.

Han would shoot first? Are you implying that Captain Malcom Reynolds has the hutspa or tact of Greedo?! Mal isn't Greedo. Mals better than Greedo and we can all agree on that.

Did you see the pilot of Serenity? Malcom took out the agent trying to collect the bounty on summer and he never saw it coming.

Lemme paint you a picture: We're at Mos Eisley, Han gets up to conduct his buisness after extorting and agreeing to take a teenager and and old fart to a planet that odds are won't exist anymore, Mal walks up - AND SHOOTS - no hello, no dialogue (unlike Star Wars). Game over. His quips will come after chewie sees his friend bleeding on the floor.

Anonymous | Tue, 07/11/2006 - 18:25

Who would win in a fight...

Suggestions for further rounds:

Ferris Buller Vs. Parker Lewis

Captain Jack Sparrow Vs. Indiana Jones

Spider-man Vs. Daredevil (not MOVIE BASED)

Jason Von Stein Vs. Jason Norred

Anonymous | Tue, 07/11/2006 - 18:36

I think all of them should

I think all of them should be seperate rounds, lol.

disillusion2112 | Tue, 02/12/2008 - 13:58

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

User login

Navigation

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 7 guests online.